This is Coming From Someone Who Owns an SEO Company

I’ve been doing SEO for over 22 years, and there’s something I tell people that surprises them:

SEO isn’t the right investment for every business.

You’d think I’d tell everyone they need SEO. I don’t.

In fact, I’ve talked people out of hiring us because I didn’t think it would give them a good return.

As a rough rule of thumb, once a business gets to around $500,000 or more in annual revenue, SEO usually starts making a lot more sense. There are plenty of exceptions, but businesses around that level have often built enough momentum that SEO can produce a strong return.

The key isn’t the revenue.

It’s what usually comes along with it.

SEO Hasn’t Changed as Much as People Think

Whether you call it SEO, AI search, GEO, or whatever the latest acronym is, the fundamentals haven’t really changed.

Search engines and AI systems are both trying to answer one question:

“Who should I trust?”

To earn that trust, you need two things:

• Authority
• Relevant content

That’s really it.

Google needs enough confidence to rank your website. AI systems need enough confidence to recommend or cite it. Different technology. Same basic idea.

Authority Is More Than Backlinks

Years ago, authority was mostly measured by backlinks.

Today, backlinks still matter, but they’re only one piece of the puzzle.

Google also looks at signals like:

• How often people search for your business by name
• Whether people click on your website in search results
• The quality and quantity of your reviews
• Mentions of your business around the web
• Overall reputation and credibility

Every year Google gets better at recognizing businesses that have earned authority naturally.

And every year it gets better at spotting businesses trying to fake it.

The Part Most Businesses Miss

Here’s something I’ve seen over and over:

• A company calls and says, “We want to start SEO.”
• Then I look at the website.
• They haven’t added meaningful content in three years.
• There are no helpful articles.
• No resources.
• No new service pages.
• No signs that the website has been growing along with the business.

That’s a problem.

SEO isn’t something you flip to on, like a light bulb.

It works best when you already have a habit of publishing useful information.

Think about it this way. If I told you I wanted to help you rank for 300 different searches, where is that content going to come from?

It has to be written.

That’s why I encourage businesses to keep improving their websites long before they’re ready to invest heavily in SEO. Every helpful article, every new service page, every frequently asked question, and every case study becomes another opportunity for Google and AI search to understand what you do.

Why Growing Businesses Have an Advantage

The reason I use the revenue benchmark has nothing to do with the number itself.

Businesses that have reached a certain size have usually been doing a lot of the right things already:

• They’ve served customers.
• They’ve collected reviews.
• People know who they are.
• Other websites mention them.

Hopefully, they’ve been adding content over the years instead of letting their website sit untouched.

When all of those pieces are in place, SEO becomes much easier.

We’re no longer trying to build everything from scratch.

We’re expanding what’s already there.

That’s why you’ll sometimes see a business invest in SEO and experience tremendous growth. They already had the authority and the foundation. They just needed someone to organize it, target the right keywords, create the missing content, and improve the technical side of the site.

Where SEO Agencies Hit a Wall

Can an SEO agency help build authority?

Absolutely.

Can we improve your technical SEO?

Yes.

Can we research keywords, optimize pages, earn quality backlinks, and create great content?

Of course.

But no agency can manufacture years of credibility overnight.

That’s where I think some businesses waste money.

They’re hoping an SEO company can make up for years of not investing in their website.

It doesn’t work that way.

The businesses that get the biggest wins from SEO are usually the ones that have already been investing in their business. SEO simply amplifies what they’ve already built.

If You’re Not Ready Yet

If your business is still growing, I probably wouldn’t put every marketing dollar into SEO.

I’d focus on building the foundation.

That means things like:

• Publishing useful blog posts and articles
• Expanding your service pages
• Creating helpful resources for customers
• Building your social media presence
• Earning more reviews
• Networking with other businesses
• Getting mentioned by organizations, partners, and local media

Those activities make your business stronger whether Google exists or not.

Later, when you’re ready to invest more heavily in SEO, you’ll already have the authority and the content needed to make that investment pay off.

My Take

I own an SEO company, and I still tell people not to hire us sometimes.

Not because SEO doesn’t work. Because timing matters.

If you’ve built a solid business, have been adding useful content, and people know who you are, SEO can become one of the highest-return marketing investments you’ll make.

But if your website has been sitting untouched for years, don’t expect SEO to fix that overnight.

Start by building something worth ranking. Then let SEO amplify it. Don’t put the cart before the horse, as they say.

📄 Download a PDF of This Article